Brotherhood Mutual Insurance Company Insurance Brotherhood Mutual Insurance Company Visit Website P.O. Box 2227 Fort Wayne, IN 46801 (260) 482-8668 (800) 333-3735 (260) 483-7525 (fax) About Rep Info About Property and Liability Insurance for Churches and related ministries. Whom to Contact Johs Lederman Senior Claims Adjuster Phone: (260) 482-8668 Erica Smith Director - Underwriting Product Quality & Developm Phone: (260) 482-8668